During this Wednesday’s Associated Students of the University of Idaho senate meeting, resolution F26-R16 passed condemning “harmful rhetoric” in response to Turning Point USA’s event “Feminism is a Cancer” being held at the Bruce Pitman Center on Thursday, Nov. 19 at 7 p.m.
During the senate meeting, President Scott Green released an email communication to students at 7:48 p.m., coincidentally sent during debate of F26-R16.
In President Green’s email statement, “Some have reached out to express concern about the negative characterization this week’s Turning Point event appears to make toward women and those who support them. The university is not a sponsor of this event, but as a public institution, we have a constitutional obligation and duty to uphold the right to free speech and provide space for peaceful civil protest and expression of opinions.”
Resolution F26-R16 was passed unanimously by the 12 senators in attendance. The legislation was written by ASUI Director of Student Involvement Preston Hardcastle, and the two students who will be holding a protest before the event, Silas Morris and Aurelia Crockett.
The language of the bill states, “advertising displaying the phrase “Feminism is a Cancer” has been placed around campus to promote the event and this promotional campaign has brought degrading rhetoric into shared campus spaces that students use, prompting students to bring their concerns to ASUI; and, WHEREAS, feminism is a broad term that encompasses movements that have advanced women’s rights, educated opportunities, and personal autonomy, and describing it as a “cancer” portrays the pursuit of equality as a society-wide disease.”
The event is being headlined by speakers Joshua Hames and Seth Gruber, who are both podcasters. Gruber is the CEO of the White Rose Resistance, a national movement, that “is committed to confronting the silence of the American church on abortion, and inspiring action,” according to their website. Joshua Haymes holds a show called, “Reformation Red Pill,” works as a pastor, and is from Nashville, Tennessee.
Bill sponsor, senator Emilie Guardado said, “Our university should be a place where all students and staff feel safe, welcome, and like they belong. A phrase like “Feminism is a cancer” goes against that in so many ways. While we value freedom of speech and expression, we should not allow rhetoric that dehumanizes our fellow students.”
“I’ve heard a lot of comments on social media from family back home in California,” said senator Envee Carter, “this has reached their social media, and its heartbreaking to hear about. This is how our school is being represented at this moment… I don’t believe that the University should be represented as a school that allows this type of behavior.”
“Last year, TPUSA club members have followed my friends multiple times in class, harassing them and yelling harmful slurs at them, targeting their sexual orientation… I came to ASUI to speak to the senate to get a resolution passed, but due to the timing…they were not able to write a resolution before the end of the school year. I think this is an action that we can take as ASUI to show that the history of this club…making students feel unsafe on campus, and doing what they call “rage bait activity” in order to up their engagement,” said Senator Rainey Roecker.
In an email interview, President of TPUSA, Jacob Gartell was asked by the Argonaut, “What do you/TPUSA want to display when it comes to the “Feminism is a Cancer” title?”
Gartell said, “I personally reached out to both guests and I personally picked the title of the talk and I then pitched the talk to LI [the Leadership Institute] for their help and they liked it so they sponsored it. Now all of this was being approved as I went. I checked in with both of my bosses (both of whom are women) as I was finalizing this event.”
In a follow-up the Argonaut asked, “Where you expecting this kind of response from students to the Free to Speak Tour?”
“As far as what I was expecting, I was expecting all of this and more. I knew what I was getting myself into, I knew the nerve I had touched before I announced this topic. But as is consistent with Turning Point, just because something is controversial doesn’t mean it is off limits, besides, facts don’t care about your feelings,” Gartell said.
In senate debate on F26-B16, Senator Roecker described his interaction with the Dean of Students office, after telling them about his friends experience , “I’ve spoken with the Dean of Students last year, and their faculty advisor, and the head of security on campus, and multiple other campus resources, on behalf of multiple of their [TPUSA’s] behaviors, that are effecting students sense of safety, and pretty much received gotten the same result… similar to President Green’s email that was just sent out 30 minutes ago,” said senator Roecker.
President Green’s email statement continued, “Under our Constitution, you and every American citizen has the right to assemble and practice our First Amendment rights; and as a public university, we always support the civil exchange of ideas…While free speech does not protect speech that threatens personal safety, it does protect words you may personally view as ‘hateful speech.’”
In continued senate debate, Senator Isaias Veras-Ramirez said, “We are a university, we are supposed to encourage discussing challenging perspectives different then our own. But challenging these perspectives requires regarding the people or movements associated with it. You can disagree with feminism, you can criticize it and question it, that is your right. But when the pursuit of equal rights is publicly compared to a disease, I believe we have a right to question the messaging and explain why it has been placed.”
In the same Argonaut interview TPUSA president Gartell said, “I would say that since the whole Feminist movement is based on this communistic structure and the motor for its change is emotional appeals with no logic behind it I knew the kind of push back to expect. I was and am ready for the event to spark an immensely strong emotional reaction with no ability to have a logical conversation about it.”
Josie Adjanohoun can be reached at [email protected]


