In Idaho, being a Republican is usually enough to win a statewide election. But I think there is a
big difference between winning an election and actually earning the support of a large majority
of Idahoans.
The 2026 election results show something that I think deserves more attention. Republican
Secretary of State Phil McGrane received 67.39% of the vote, while Attorney General Raúl
Labrador received 59.84%, and U.S. Sen. Jim Risch received just 56.53%.
All three Republicans won their elections, but the difference in their percentages is hard to
ignore.
McGrane received nearly 11 percentage points more than Risch and more than 7 points more
than Labrador. These were different races with different opponents, so the results don’t tell us
exactly why voters made their choices. Still, I think they raise an important question: Why do
some politicians seem to connect with more Idahoans than others?
To me, a lot of it comes down to how they carry themselves and how they approach their jobs.
What I admire about Phil McGrane is that I don’t feel like I’m constantly being dragged into a
political argument when I hear from him. He is a Republican, and he certainly has his own
political beliefs, but I don’t get the impression that everything he does is about scoring points for
his party.
Instead, I see someone who is focused on doing his job and protecting the interests of
Idahoans.
One example that really stood out to me was his disagreement with the Trump administration
over access to Idaho voter information.
Earlier this year, the Department of Justice requested voter registration information that included
sensitive personal details. McGrane refused to turn over that information, arguing that Idaho law
protects it and that his office had a responsibility to safeguard voters’ privacy.
The Justice Department disagreed and filed a lawsuit against him in April, arguing that federal
law gave it the authority to obtain the records for election oversight.Regardless of where someone stands on that legal dispute, I think McGrane’s decision
deserves attention.
President Trump has enormous political support in Idaho. Going against his administration is not
necessarily the easiest position for an Idaho Republican to take. Yet McGrane stood by his
interpretation of the law and his responsibility to the people whose information he oversees.
I see that as a pretty selfless example of public service. I can’t know what political
consequences he expected, but I respect his willingness to take that position despite the
potential backlash.
That’s the kind of independence I wish we saw more often.
I don’t think elected officials should spend their time worrying only about the 55% or 60% of
voters who supported them. Once someone takes office, they have a responsibility to the entire
state, including the people who voted against them.
That is where I think Idaho politics could improve.
I would like to see our attorney general’s office, in particular, take a less politically
confrontational approach. I’m not saying Labrador should abandon his beliefs or stop taking
positions he thinks are right. I just believe there is a difference between standing up for your
principles and making politics the center of everything.
We have gotten to a point where political disagreements too often turn personal, and campaigns
seem increasingly willing to drag each other through the mud. I don’t think that is what public
service should be about.
This isn’t even something unique to Idaho.
Look at Vermont, where Republican Gov. Phil Scott won another term in 2026 despite serving in
a state that generally favors Democrats. Scott’s political approach is different from that of many
national Republicans, and his continued success is another reason to question the idea that
politicians must always follow their party’s political direction.
Obviously, Idaho and Vermont are very different states. But I think both give us a reason to
reconsider what voters might value in their elected officials.
I’m not suggesting that McGrane’s election percentage proves everyone agrees with him or that
his style alone explains his success. Voters have plenty of reasons for supporting different
candidates.
But I do think the numbers matter. A Republican receiving 67% in Idaho is not the same
electoral result as one receiving 56%, even when both win comfortably.We should be asking why those differences exist instead of treating every Republican victory as
the same.
I want politicians who are willing to work with people they disagree with, who can defend their
principles without constantly attacking someone else, and who remember that their
responsibility doesn’t end with the people who voted for them.
To me, Phil McGrane represents an approach to politics that we could use a lot more of.
Maybe reducing political polarization doesn’t require everyone to agree. Maybe it starts with
electing people who understand that they are supposed to serve their state, not just their party.
And that is something I think Idahoans, regardless of political affiliation, should be able to
appreciate.
Sent in by Carter Durst.

