The University of Idaho Argonaut

Tuesday
Feb 09th
  • Login
  • Sign up
    Registration
    Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.
    Name: *
    Username: *
    E-mail: *
    Password: *
    Verify Password: *
  • Search
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Home arrow Sports arrow Kentucky Derby senseless
Kentucky Derby senseless Print E-mail
Written by Cheyenne Hollis - Argonaut   
Monday, 04 May 2009
The 135th Kentucky Derby was run last weekend, and quite frankly, it is the most ridiculous event in all of American sports. After watching the latest incarnation of the event on Saturday, it is time for the public to call time on the Derby.
The arguments for the Kentucky are simple and one-dimensional. The event makes a lot of money, and there is tradition involved. Aside from those two things, there are no redeeming qualities.

There have been plenty of items in history that made money and had a rich tradition but lost usefulness over time. One will struggle to find rotary phones or medical products ending with the word elixir for this very reason.

When the Kentucky Derby started, horses were the fastest way to travel and played a major part in society. I highly doubt anyone in attendance at Churchill Downs traveled to the event by hopping in his or her buggy led by a reliable steed.

Horse racing is obsolete, just like leather helmets in football or baseball managers wearing suits in the dugout. However, I get the sneaking suspicion those in attendance at the Derby would argue both sports would be better off going back to those traditions.

Speaking of uncomfortable traditions, the Kentucky Derby broadcast made the event seem like a giant social event for middle-aged white people. The commentators kept tossing out words like “pageantry” and “spectacle” to describe the Derby, but that hardly legitimizes the proceedings. Those Ben Hur Roman chariot races were definitely a spectacle but no one in Italy is clamoring for those to return.

There is an incredibly sleazy element about the Derby that cannot be hidden by horses running around a track for two minutes. While defenders of the Kentucky Derby claim it is about horse racing, it is most certainly not about horse racing.

The only people who care about horse racing are those directly involved in the sport and those make their living placing wagers in off track betting parlors. I would hazard a guess and say all of the people at the event, and watching on television, probably did not fall in either category.

I understand people love stories that involve animals, and there is something majestic about horses that captivate the public. Still, you get the feeling racing horses are the jerks of the horse community.

A lot of them are using steroids, they get preferential treatment and some of them look downright vicious. I know if for some reason I became a horse these would not be the horses I chose to eat my oats and hay with.

If it is the case of people wanting to see animals compete, then why not try to exploit the market by making cuter animals race?

You would think someone would start racing puppies, baby sheep or polar bears because the public would just eat that up. Cute animal racing is an idea with some potential.

That is, of course, if horse racing is about people being interested because animals are involved. While there may be a percentage who tune in for that reason but the real reason for the Kentucky Derby’s population was unspoken and rather disturbing.

At the core, the Derby is an event were the Southern gentry get to dress funny, get hammered and have the public marvel at how lucky they are. It would seem the first Saturday in May is not a sporting event but a propaganda vehicle used to convince those who attend and watch that their way of life was not so bad.

I understand race is a sensitive subject in this country, especially places like Kentucky, but when a bunch of dudes are dressed up like Colonel Sanders and Colonel Reb, the comically inappropriate former mascot of Ole Miss, at a sporting event, there are some problems.

If those in charge of horse racing see their sport as necessary, then perhaps it is time the showcase event removes the alarming traditions in which it is currently steeped in. Watching the Kentucky Derby serves as a reminder of just how far sports in America have come since the draconian era of segregation and exclusivity.


Add as favorites (51) | Views: 2121

Comments (9)
1. 05-05-2009 06:59
 
Keep BIAS out of your Articles
If you were a REAL journalist, I wouldn't be able to guess the color of your skin from reading your opinion on a HORSE RACE. If you associated everything about an era with slavery, then you shouldn't be wearing cotton fabrics because they remind you of slavery and you shouldn't be stepping foot into any plantation-style architectural building because they remind you of racism. You've written an appalling article associated apples with oranges. Honey, get your head out of ass and get with the times. I'm white, I voted Obama president and this horce race has got nothing to with segregation and exclusivity. It's a friggen social event and sports event. Just like the opens Serena and Venus participate in. The chip in your shoulder will continue to exist until YOU CEASE TO SEE IT and you're going to shoot more than one of your dreams in the foot if you don't stop this, Cheyenne Hollis.
Registered
 
unbiased
2. 05-05-2009 10:56
 
Not so much...
Cheyenne is the farthest from a racist and last I checked he is also white. Stop playing the race card whitey, you embarrass us all.
Registered
 
Vandalax12
3. 05-05-2009 14:58
 
Worst Article Ever
This has to be the worst article I have ever read. Please don't write about topics you obviously know nothing about. This newspaper should be embarrassed to have a so called 'journalist' like yourself. And to think, that Idaho has played an important part in horse racing today. If you can't figure out what I mean, you have no business writing about the sport.
Registered
 
DS213
4. 05-05-2009 15:03
 
Race accusations
This article, on second read, throws many race accusations out there. This journalist needs to jump ahead to reality... 
 
Again, is this newspaper proud of this article? It should be ashamed.
Registered
 
DS213
5. 05-05-2009 15:45
 
Future of Journalism... Here Now!
Dear Ms. Hollis, 
 
I'm afraid this is one of the worst articles I've had the burden of reading in some time. Your lack of research and knowledge on the subject was painfully obvious. The article rambles from one circular argument to the next, culminating in an ad hominem attack on a breed of horses. 
 
Please tell me you were satirically calling thoroughbred horses bullies and motioning for puppy races. If not, I fear for the future of the Idaho journalism program.
Registered
 
J.Anderson
6. 05-05-2009 18:00
 
Race Card
Vandalax- Sorry, but the race card was already played by the author of this ludicrous article.....try again.......
Registered
 
DS213
7. 05-05-2009 18:16
 
from MI
yea I would agree this individual is describing something with only a brief and light understanding. If it was for a class F on research, A- on style, overall F since its intent was publishing in the school paper; the quality, ethics and veracity of a journalist is never to be taken lightly. This works in the debate club or lawyering or politics or talk radio, but not in the real world. 
 
Anyway, see the local paper in KY has hundreds of pictures speaking billions of words that refute everything decribed by the writer.  
 
http://www.courier-journal.com/ 
 
the pics will probably be gone from the website in the next week or so!!
Registered
 
samsosa
8. 06-05-2009 04:30
 
Just assuming it doesn't make it so
I suppose that none of the horsemen involved made their way to Louisville on foot either, so I guess that in your opinion track & field has been “obsolete” since mankind invented the wheel. 
 
Your article suffers from the fact that you consider your assumptions to be a given. How do you know that the crowd would have prefered leather-helmet football. I wouldn’t think so, instead I would say that this is one of several examples where you try to gloss over the fact that you don’t have an argument with a pathetic attempt to poke fun. It backfires, because it’s obvious that your own ignorance is the root of your problem. 
 
Most racing fans would agree that Derby Day isn’t just about the races, but the Super Bowl isn’t only about the sport either, nor is the World Series. I would harzard a guess of my own and say that you might find someone at the SB who isn’t schooled in the subtleties of d-line tactics. Comes with the territory for popular and tradition-rich events. 
 
So what if it’s a little posh? It’s pretty much a singular event in American racing. I myself prefer the atmosphere at the Preakness, but then again nobody forces me to be at Churchill. And certainly nobody gives me, or you, the right to call for something to be stopped just because it’s not my cup of tea. 
 
Do what I do: watch the races and hit the “mute” button if something is too far off for your taste. Or in your case: don’t tune in at all. Spend the day with some friends who are dressed as you are and share the same limitations in basic logic, so you can pat each other on the back for how much more tolerant and less smug you are than that Southern gentry (of which everyone at Churchill is a part; which you know for a fact because you assume). 
 
If you don’t understand this fascinating sport that’s your problem, not everyone else’s. If you think that nobody but a small group of pro gamblers cares about the races, you obviously lack knowledge. It's disturbing that an article with such utter disregard for journalistic principles can make its way into the newspaper at UI. I don’t know what made you think you were qualified to write this article. I guess you just assumed.
Registered
 
malcer
9. 06-05-2009 10:16
 
my saying it makes it so!
You're senseless. And also obsolete.
Registered
 
righthind

Write Comment
  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
  • Personal verbal attacks will be deleted.
  • Please don't use comments to plug your web site. Such material will be removed.
  • Just ensure to *Refresh* your browser for a new security code to be displayed prior to clicking on the 'Send' button.
  • Keep in mind that the above process only applies if you simply entered the wrong security code.
Name:
Title:
Comment:

 
 
 
Moscow, ID
Mostly CloudyToday: Mostly Cloudy
Hi 42°F
Lo 31°F
More...